I thought Jam #1 might have been from June 2009 because it had some jams with that "cicada" sound. The fact that the jam sounds like it was going into Ghost doesn't help with the identification process either.

I noticed that every other Aug '98 show was featured in MJM and 8/11/98 Jim was the cherry on top. I don't know if that factored into the choice, but it certainly worked out well. I might be mistaken, but I could have sworn I saw a review of 8/11 where a couple chit chatted with Page pre-show and mentioned how they liked Time Loves a Hero and casually mentioned it would be cool to hear it again as Page was leaving.