You know, I was annoyed when I first read this review and was going to post a snarky reply, but got distracted. I am glad I did because after thinking about it, I get why one would not like much/all/some of the set. The weirdness and disjointedness of the lyrics and music is necessarily part of the gag. And, if it didn't work for you, it didn't work for you. Personally, while I am still digesting it, I think it is some of the freshest, funnest Phish I've heard in a while.