@J_D_G said:

@Chipes said:

Why would they even post a review by someone who wasn't even there? It's pretty worthless IMO. And all of the negative comments that follow are also by people looking through a 16:9 peep-hole from their couch. Not the best versions I've heard of every song, as some of you seem to expect...but it was raunchy, tight and had a good momentum throughout. If you prefer Trey "noodling" around for 20 minutes in the name of experimentation, throw on a show from '97. If you want to hear a really solid show that may end up as one of the best this tour...listen to Saturday and judge for yourself. I have both shows up on dropbox...PM me if you want the link.

Just curious, were you at this particular show?

While, I get what you're going for here, I don't think its a relevant question. Said commenter isn't offering to review the show. When you're reviewing a band whose main forum is their live show, the energy in the room, amphitheater,etc... is such an integral part of the experience. I also feel I have read some lackluster reviews of shows I have been at, where I have thought to myself "Man, if they were there they might have been a little more jazzed about this show." Y'all get too touchy about comments on here once in a while. If you're going to offer up personal comments and criticisms of shows on a public platform, be prepared to take the good and the bad.