@sethadam1 said:

@FACTSAREUSELESS, @steelcon58

So, let me get this straight: once deemed "a reviewer," one should only write brainless praise of every show, critical evaluation is not acceptable, and, oh yeah, every show must be above average. Is that the assertion?

If you want a fair review of a show in context of other Phish shows, come to Phish.net. If you just want mutual masturbation and to leave with the idea that every show is "Must see! that was the coming of Phish 4.0!", look elsewhere. Plenty of blogs will only shower praise on every performance.

Incidentally, I think this review seems generous, given the thick marshmallow spread over Carini, which practically dubs it immortal. And we're one night into tour.

So you can be critical by I cannot? Really? So you rate among the faithful but I don't. Hey that's cool.

BTW you're wrong. I love this forum and I think it's awesome. But it's not the only place to get honest and fair reviews. I thought the review on JamBase was excellent for this show, and unbiased, and more accurate.