I think @bertolet down seems like a rather happy fellow, actually. A happy fellow that's seen a lot of Phish, and hence has good reason to be. And good reason to be balanced, fair, and critical of the band with a sense of the big picture when writing a review.

Chew on this: I think a few people could maybe do well to take a step back and wonder why reading a critique of a show (a critique implies informed criticism, not unquestioned lauding) gets them so riled up to the point of questioning whether said reviewer has "issues."