I absolutely loved the 10.16.10 and Bethel Crosseyed and Painless performances so I'm definitely not ready to give up on that tune. The Merriweather version was arguably better than both of those for 11 minutes, just needed another few minutes of exploration (still waiting...).

Agree with your review though, song choices in the second set were a little odd, but overall I left really impressed. 1st set and encore were some of the best I've seen, and 2nd set had plenty of songs I love. Trey is playing his ass off, so, can't really complain, but it would nice to see some more flowing second sets, cohesive stanzas of music. Come on Phish you can do it!