@jkrim716 said:

Personally I dont like the sound of this. I dont think the audience should be able to sway the direction of the shows, the band should have full control in taking the show any direction they want to go. Thats what leads to such different and creative shows, its all in the musicians. I think that would kill what many of these bands strive to go for. The best kinds of shows are where Phish really feels the music, and playing exactly what the audience wants to ruins that.

1. any band who could actually pull this off would only do it once to a few times a year.

2. Trey (and probably the rest of the band) would 100% agree with you, and Phish would never do something like this just because thats how they are, plus it wasnt their original idea